Why anxiety therapy sometimes makes OCD worse, and what to do instead

The coping skills weren't wrong. They were aimed at a different problem.


You've been doing everything right. You learned to catch anxious thoughts and question them. You practice breathing when your heart starts racing. When the worry gets loud, you check in with someone you trust, and they help you see it more clearly.

And one particular fear keeps getting bigger. You've gotten very good at talking yourself down from it. You just have to do it more and more often.

When I hear this, I start wondering whether what's being treated as anxiety is actually OCD. The two can look almost identical from the inside, but they run on different mechanisms, and some of the tools that help anxiety can keep OCD going.

How anxiety and OCD look alike

Both involve distress, avoidance, and relief when you get away from the trigger. In anxiety, the pattern is fairly straightforward: something feels uncomfortable, you avoid it, you feel better, and over time your world gets a little smaller. Treatment works by gradually facing what you've been avoiding so your nervous system learns it can handle it.

OCD has the same outline, but the relief comes from somewhere specific. An intrusive thought shows up, and you do something to neutralize it: check, review, ask, confess, replay, pray, figure it out. That response is a compulsion. It brings the distress down for a while, and in doing so it teaches your brain that the thought was dangerous and needed handling. So the thought comes back, with more urgency.

Where anxiety tools turn into compulsions

This is the part most people haven't heard. In OCD, the problem isn't only what you do. It's what the action is for. A lot of standard anxiety tools can quietly become another way to get relief from the obsession.

  • Reassurance. In anxiety, a calm voice of reason can be genuinely helpful. In OCD, reassurance works for minutes or hours and then the question returns, sometimes reworded. Needing to ask again is the signature of a compulsion.

  • Challenging the thought. Weighing the evidence for and against a fear is a core anxiety skill. With OCD, it becomes mental reviewing. You win the argument, and the doubt simply finds a new angle.

  • Calming techniques. Breathing and grounding are useful tools. But if they're being used specifically to make the intrusive thought go away, they can serve the same function as any other ritual.

  • "Sitting with it." Tolerating discomfort is exactly right. The catch is that many people sit with it while silently reviewing, reassuring themselves, or neutralizing. The form of the compulsion changes. The loop doesn't.

None of this means your old therapist did something wrong. ERP training isn't standard in most graduate programs, and OCD is easy to miss when it looks like worry.

How to tell which one you're dealing with

The question I find most useful isn't what are you avoiding but what is the avoidance trying to prevent? In anxiety, people are often trying to avoid a feeling, like panic or embarrassment. In OCD, they're usually trying to prevent a feared outcome or settle a doubt: that something is contaminated, that they might cause harm, that they've done something unforgivable, that they don't really love their partner.

The second clue is what happens with reassurance. If one answer is never enough, if checking once becomes checking three times, that pattern points toward OCD. And anxiety and OCD can absolutely exist at the same time, which is part of why it's worth sorting out which one is driving which symptom.

What OCD treatment does differently

Exposure and response prevention (ERP) is the most well-supported treatment for OCD. It looks a bit like anxiety exposure work, but the target is different.

In ERP, the plan is built around compulsions: which responses we're going to stop doing, not just which situations we're going to face. Progress isn't measured by whether the anxiety goes down. It's measured by your ability to let the doubt stay unresolved without doing anything to fix it.

That includes how therapy itself works. If you have OCD, I'm not going to keep reassuring you that the thought isn't true, even though it might feel kinder in the moment. I'll help you stop needing the answer.

If this sounds familiar

If you've done a lot of anxiety work and one fear refuses to move, it's worth getting a clear read on whether OCD is part of the picture. Read more about OCD therapy and ERP, or book a free 15-minute consultation if you're in Arizona or Colorado.

Previous
Previous

Why avoiding shame keeps it around longer

Next
Next

Why so many people with OCD don't get better in therapy, and what actually works